GitWikiSuggestions

This page is for recording (or discussion) of Suggestions about the the [[FrontPage|GitWiki]] Web site.

Make sure your suggestion doesn’t exist already or that your question has already been answered by checking HelpContents.

---

Table of contents

<<(2)>>

---

Editing

SVN comparison page name needs typo fix

The GitSvnComparsion page has very good content, but should really be named GitSvnComparison; I already fixed the spelling ("comparsion" -> "comparison") in the page itself. It will also be easier to find via search engines ...

I thought it safer and more polite to leave the page rename fix to someone other than a first-time visitor. Thanks.

SVN comparison page might want to compare the storing of binary files in each system

The GitSvnComparsion page has very good content, but it would be nice to know the differences between the two in how binary files are stored and whether either uses a differential backup vs a file level backup.

Parsers

It would be nice to have installed parsers from [[MoinMoin:ParserMarket|ParserMarket]] (see [[MoinMoin:ParserMarket#head-17c33967bbb4345a453627b944bad1f1bc4b2791|Installation Instructions]] there) for languages used in Git, Cogito and examples, i.e for Perl, shell and e.g. diff.

• Perl parsers from [[MoinMoin:ParserMarket|ParserMarket]]: parser/Perl by Johannes Hoerburger (`.py` extension needs to be aded).
• diff output parsers from [[MoinMoin:ParserMarket|ParserMarket]]: parser/diff.py by Emilio Lopes.

Error in GUI editing

When editing in gui mode, and pressing text-mode, all blank lines are removed, and ({) curly-braces are replaced with square ones ([), causing things like \{\{TableOfContents(2)\}\} and \{\{BR\}\} not to work! This especially seams to be a problem on the [[[InterfacesFrontendsAndTools]]] page.

InterWiki Links

It would be nice if there were shorter InterWiki links for linking to the Git and Cogito documentation, both HTML version and gitweb sources. One of the way of adding InterWiki link is to modify site's `data/intermap.txt` file.

For git and cogito manpages online it would mean that instead of writing for example

[http://www.kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-apply.html git-apply(1)]

(git-apply(1)) use (proposal) GitDoc InterWiki link, i.e. use one of the following (ones that are possible to create)

[wiki:GitDoc:git-apply git-apply(1)]
GitDoc:git-apply

if it is not possible). Analogous for Cogito docs.

For links to file in the git.git source via gitweb, instead of using for example

[http://www.kernel.org/git/?p=git/git.git;a=blob;hb=HEAD;f=Documentation/git-apply.txt git-apply.txt]

(git-apply.txt) use GitSource InterWiki link

[wiki:GitSource:Documentation/git-apply.txt git-apply.txt]

---

Would be also of use to have InterWiki links for common [[GitCommunity|GitMailingList]] archives, i.e. MARC and GMane, similarly like there is now MsgID InterWiki link?

New Pages

Here a few suggestions for new pages.

Best Practice Page

• commit message: short summary (<80 characters and not the beginning sentence continuing in second line) \n\n long description

  Reason: emailed patches, oneline log, gitweb overview.
  Some tools currently insert new lines after the first line if there is none. This may be considered as a bug and should be fixed.

• branching is easy and fast, use it (encourage topic branches)
• rebase if you've been the only person working on the branch to prevent unnecessary merges (making the history complicated)
• do not rewind history on public repositories or repositories used by someone else than you, it will cause confusion

Development Page

• common pitfalls
  • run make test after patching
  • check for correct whitespaces (tabs, no spaces for indentation, no space at eol)
• editor settings

  vim:tabstop=8:softtabstop=8:shiftwidth=8:noexpandtab:textwidth=80 for C files
  documentation seems to use a bit less than 80 for the textwidth most of the time, is there any recommendation for that?

• mua settings

  Is it possible in some user agents to reply automatically to all people in a thread and the mailing list? If so please post configuration options :)

• mutt: press g (group-reply) but this may set the wrong followup-to header

Merging pages

IndexFile and WhatIsIndex

• IndexFile and WhatIsTheIndex pages are about nearly the same topic; perhaps they should be merged into one page.

Random stuff

• Why is there always a Git-prefix to the wiki pages?

---

CategoryWebInterfaces CategoryWebInterfaces